Teens UnEdited: Claim Your Identity
← Back to the notebook
For Parents

I Followed Them for Eight Years. The Hours Were Not the Problem.

Most of what parents hear about phones compares different kids at one moment. BYU's Sarah Coyne followed the same teens for eight years and found that when a teen's own social media time rose, her own depression did not.

I Followed Them for Eight Years. The Hours Were Not the Problem.
Screen
Drawing on research by
Sarah M. Coyne (Brigham Young University)
·
Read the study →

Most of what you have been told about your daughter's phone rests on a comparison that cannot support it.

The standard study takes a large group of teenagers at one moment, sorts them by how much time they spend on social media, and reports that the heavy users are doing worse. That finding is real and it is reported accurately. What it cannot tell you is the direction. Teenagers who are already struggling may use more. The comparison is between different children, and different children differ for a hundred reasons.

Sarah Coyne ran the study that fixes the comparison, and the result is not the one the headlines prepared you for.

Coyne is a professor of human development and associate director of the School of Family Life at Brigham Young University, where she leads Project M.E.D.I.A., a longitudinal study that follows the same adolescents year after year instead of sampling a crowd once. In 2020, with Adam Rogers, Jessica Zurcher, Laura Stockdale and McCall Booth, she published "Does time spent using social media impact mental health?: An eight year longitudinal study" in Computers in Human Behavior.

They followed roughly five hundred adolescents, with questionnaires every year, from around thirteen to around twenty. And they asked the question almost nobody asks, because it requires eight years of data to ask it at all.

Not: do heavy users look worse than light users? But: when a particular teenager increases her own social media use, does her own depression or anxiety go up?

It did not. Within individuals, across eight years, the increases in time did not track increases in distress. The authors' conclusion was that the field should move past screen time.

I want to be careful about what that does and does not mean, because this is the point where both camps start misquoting the study. It does not mean nothing is wrong. It does not mean social media is harmless, and it does not mean your worry is foolish. What it means is narrower and more useful: the variable we have all been managing, the number of hours, is not the variable doing the work. We have spent a decade on a dial that is not connected to much.

Which, if you are running a household, is genuinely good news. You have been fighting about the wrong number. You can stop.

The fifth book in The Unmistakably You Series, Glow Up. For Real., is not undercut by that result. It is sharpened by it, to the only version worth defending. If the platform as such were doing the damage, hours would track distress, and across eight years within the same young people they do not. So what is left is what she does there. Whether she is comparing. Whether she is performing. Whether the version of herself she posts is one she would recognize across a table.

That is a harder thing to measure than hours and a much better question to ask.

So change the question at home. "How long were you on there" has an answer you both already know and it starts a negotiation. "Who do you feel worse than after you have been on there" has an answer that is actually diagnostic, and she may not tell you the first time, and that is fine, because you have shown her which thing you think matters.

And notice that the hours are not nothing, just not what we thought. Time has an opportunity cost. An hour is an hour not sleeping, not with a friend in a room, not practicing something badly. That is a real argument against the hours and it is honest. It is not the same as claiming the hours cause depression.

For educators. Any school policy built on time limits is built on the weakest finding in this literature, and the policy has a hidden cost: it signals to students that adults are managing a number rather than understanding an experience, which is precisely why they stop talking to adults about it. The stronger intervention is comparison literacy. Teach explicitly that a feed is a curated highlight reel subject to selection, that the comparison it invites is statistically rigged, and that noticing the rigging is a skill. That is teachable in a lesson, costs nothing, and attacks the mechanism rather than the clock.

There is one more reason Coyne is worth your attention specifically. In a field where almost everyone is either an alarm-raiser or a dismisser, she is the person journalists call when they want the measured answer. Eight years of data on the same five hundred young people buys the right to say "not that, this" and be believed.

You have been counting the hours because the hours are countable. She was never in trouble over the hours.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

pass me a note

New reads, when they drop

Get the next piece the day it drops, plus the check-in that shows where you're editing yourself.

You're on the list. New reads land in your inbox the day they drop.
That didn't go through. Check your email address and try again.