Listen to how we introduce our children. This is my athlete. She’s our math kid. He’s the shy one. She’s the gifted one. He’s my easy child.
We say these things with love, and usually with pride. They are shorthand. They help a teacher, a coach or a grandparent understand a child quickly. None of us means any harm by them.
But children are listening, and they have been listening for a long time. A label that starts at seven is still being worn at fifteen. By then it has stopped being a description. It has become an instruction. The smart one must not look confused. The athlete must not want to quit. The easy child must not be any trouble.
A teacher who works with students identified as gifted told me she sees it every day. The moment a child is pulled out of class for a special program, the category arrives with them, and everyone treats it as who they are. Then she told me she had gone home and realized she had done the same thing with her own children.
The research on this is older than most parents realize. In 1998, psychologists Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck ran six studies with more than 400 fifth graders. Some children were praised for being smart. Others were praised for working hard. The children told they were smart then chose easier problems, and they handled failure worse. The label gave them something to protect. The researchers also noted how common the instinct is: in an earlier poll, 85 percent of parents believed that praising a child’s ability was necessary for the child to feel smart.
That is the trap in a kind label. “You’re so smart” sounds like a gift. To a child, it can sound like a standard they now have to keep meeting.
Different on Purpose, the second book in The Unmistakably You Series, comes at this from the teen’s side. It tells readers that the roles they were handed, by test scores, by a friend group, by family, are a rough draft other people wrote, and that they are allowed to revise it. As parents, we are among the people who wrote that draft. We can help with the revision.
Five ways to loosen a label
Catch one label. Notice the next time you describe your teen with a category, to them or in front of them. You don’t have to correct it. Just hear it.
Trade the noun for a verb. “You’re the artist” becomes “You kept working on that until the hands looked right.” Say what they did.
Name a quality the label hides. The athlete who is also patient with younger kids. The quiet one who is funny at home.
Ask before you assume. “Do you still love this, or are you doing it because we all expect you to?” Then be ready for either answer.
Leave room for a new answer. A teen who has been “the math kid” for ten years may need to hear that it would be fine to become something else.
We gave these labels by accident. We can loosen them on purpose.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

