Teens UnEdited: Claim Your Identity
← Back to the notebook
For Parents

She Watched It Happen to Someone Else

Most parents watch for whether their child is being targeted. Dorothy Espelage's research points to something quieter: teens learn which differences are expensive by watching what happens to someone else.

She Watched It Happen to Someone Else
Peers
Drawing on research by
Dorothy L. Espelage (UNC Chapel Hill)
·
Read the study →

The thing most parents are watching for is the obvious thing. Is my child being targeted. Is she coming home upset, is she being left out, is there a group account, is there a name for what is happening.

That is the right question and it is not the most common answer. The most common answer is that nothing happened to her at all. Something happened near her, to somebody else, and she drew a conclusion.

Dorothy Espelage has spent a career on the machinery behind that conclusion. She is the William C. Friday Distinguished Professor of Education at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, a member of the National Academy of Education, and one of the few researchers whose work genuinely changed how schools handle peer aggression.

Her central contribution is a reframing, and like most important reframings it sounds obvious once said and almost nothing in practice reflects it. Bullying, in her account, is not a problem of individual bullies and individual victims. It is social-ecological. It is produced by peer groups, by school climate, and by what the adults in the building treat as normal. The individuals are the visible surface of a system that is running.

That explains something every parent and teacher has observed and most prevention programs cannot account for. Remove the child everyone identifies as the problem and the problem frequently does not leave with him. Another student occupies the role, because the role was being generated by the room.

And it explains why the interventions that work tend to be the ones aimed at climate and adult norms rather than at the individuals involved. You are not treating two children. You are changing what a hundred of them believe is acceptable here.

Now hold that next to the second strand in her work, which is the one that should change how you listen at your own kitchen table. The students who get targeted are, repeatedly and across settings, the ones who differ visibly from whatever the local norm happens to be. Her portfolio has sustained attention to students with disabilities, to gender and sexual minority students, to immigrant students. Visible difference is the selection criterion.

Put those two findings together and you have the mechanism that matters for every other child in the building, including yours.

If aggression reliably targets visible difference, and if the whole peer group can see it happening, then every student in that room receives an education whether or not anything is ever done to her. She learns which kinds of difference are expensive here. She does not have to be the target. She only has to be present, once, and paying attention, which teenagers always are.

That is the quietest and most widespread form of the thing this series is about. This is the second book in The Unmistakably You Series, Different on Purpose, and its argument is that difference has to be chosen deliberately rather than merely permitted. Espelage's work describes the enforcement that makes the choice expensive. Your daughter did not get bullied out of the thing she loved. She watched what happened to the boy who was open about his, and she put hers away, and she never mentioned it to anyone because from her side nothing happened.

So the question to ask her is not whether anyone is being unkind to her. She will say no, and she will be telling the truth. The question is who in her grade has had a hard time of it, and what for. She will know in detail. And in the answer you will hear the list of things that are currently expensive in her school, which is the same list she is quietly using to decide what to show.

It is worth knowing how broad her portfolio is, because it is what makes her account of visible difference concrete rather than theoretical. Her work spans bullying, cyberbullying, teen dating violence and school violence prevention, with sustained attention to students with disabilities, to gender and sexual minority students, and to immigrant students. Her current projects include social-emotional learning interventions and suicide prevention for LGBTQ+ students. In other words, she has spent decades specifically with the young people who are most often selected by the mechanism, which is why she can say which differences cost most and in what settings.

For educators. The social-ecological finding has an uncomfortable institutional reading. If climate and adult norms produce the aggression, then the response that feels most decisive, identifying and sanctioning individuals, is working on the least productive layer, and it reassures the adults while leaving the generator running. The harder work is norm work: what is laughed at in your corridors, what a member of staff lets pass, how long the gap is between something being said and an adult naming it. Espelage has spent years arguing that bullying is not a rite of passage. The corollary is that it is not an accident either. It is an output, and outputs have inputs you control.

Nothing happened to her. That is exactly how she learned it.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

pass me a note

New reads, when they drop

Get the next piece the day it drops, plus the check-in that shows where you're editing yourself.

You're on the list. New reads land in your inbox the day they drop.
That didn't go through. Check your email address and try again.