Teens UnEdited: Claim Your Identity
← Back to the notebook
For Parents

We Gave Them a Deadline, and They Stopped Experimenting

Subject choices, applications, a summer that has to count. Harvard's Nancy Hill shows how a compressed path to adulthood makes teens stop trying on selves, and which kind of parent involvement actually helps.

We Gave Them a Deadline, and They Stopped Experimenting
Home
Drawing on research by
Nancy E. Hill (Harvard Graduate School of Education)
·
Read the study →

There is a conversation that happens in a lot of kitchens around the start of sophomore year of high school, and it usually starts with a form. Subject choices. Or a program with an application. Or a summer that has to count for something.

You did not invent the pressure. You are relaying it, because a system handed it to you and the system seems confident. But watch what your fifteen year old does with it. She does not experiment harder. She narrows. She picks the version of herself that already has evidence behind it and she quietly stops auditioning the others.

Nancy Hill has spent a career on why that happens, and her answer is not the one most parenting advice gives.

Hill is the Charles Bigelow Professor of Education at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and President-elect of the Society for Research in Child Development, and in 2021 she published The End of Adolescence, with Alexis Redding, through Harvard University Press. The book makes two arguments that are uncomfortable in a useful way.

The first is historical, and it will embarrass anyone who has recently said this generation is softer. Hill and Redding go back through the archives and find adults saying almost exactly the same things about young people decade after decade, in nearly the same words, for a century. The complaint recycles. Which does not prove nothing has changed, but it does mean the confident feeling that this cohort is uniquely fragile is the least reliable instinct a parent has, because every previous generation of parents had it too and most of them were wrong.

The second argument is the one that matters at your kitchen table. We have compressed the timetable to adulthood. The decisions arrive earlier, the specialization starts sooner, and the window for trying things on has been squeezed from both ends. And adolescence, in their account, is not a holding pattern before adulthood. It is the period whose actual function is experimentation. Compress it and you do not get adults faster. You get adults who never ran the experiment.

Sit that beside what your daughter is doing with the form. A teenager given no time to try selves on will pick the one that scores well and stop. That is not timidity. It is rational behavior under a deadline.

This is the second book in The Unmistakably You Series, Different on Purpose, and its claim is that difference has to be chosen rather than merely tolerated. Hill's work names the thing making that choice expensive. You cannot choose to be different on purpose if you have never had unmonitored time in which to find out what your difference is.

Her other major contribution tells you what to do about it, and it is the opposite of what most of us do when we get anxious.

With Lorraine Tyson, Hill published a meta-analysis in Developmental Psychology in 2009 on parental involvement in middle school. It asked which kinds of involvement actually raise achievement. The answer was that the involvement that works carries meaning and expectation. Talking about why the subject matters. Connecting today's work to a future she can picture. The involvement that does not work, and in places looks actively counterproductive, is the surveillance kind. Checking the homework. Monitoring the portal. Auditing.

Which is, of course, exactly what we escalate to when we are frightened. The surveillance feels like doing something because it produces a number. The meaning conversation produces nothing you can screenshot.

So, two things for this week.

Swap one audit for one conversation. Not a lecture about effort. A short, specific, genuinely curious question about why anyone would care about the thing she is studying, including the possibility that nobody should. You are not trying to make her like it. You are modeling that the question is allowed.

Then protect one block of genuinely unassigned time, and do not improve it. No enrichment, no documentation, no outcome. If you cannot find one, that is the finding, and it is worth more than any grade on the form.

For educators. The Hill and Tyson result has a direct institutional read. Much of what schools design as parental engagement is surveillance infrastructure: portals, alerts, weekly grade visibility. It is popular with parents because it is legible, and the meta-analytic evidence suggests it is the weakest lever available. The stronger lever costs almost nothing. Give parents language for the meaning conversation. One paragraph home, before a unit starts, on why this unit exists and what it is for, will do more than another notification setting. And if your school has compressed its own timetable, specializing students earlier each year because competitors do, Hill's argument is that you are removing the thing the age is for.

She narrowed because we gave her a deadline. The deadline was ours. So is the extension.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

pass me a note

New reads, when they drop

Get the next piece the day it drops, plus the check-in that shows where you're editing yourself.

You're on the list. New reads land in your inbox the day they drop.
That didn't go through. Check your email address and try again.