Teens UnEdited: Claim Your Identity
← Back to the notebook
For Parents

Whatever Happened to the Cool Kids

The thirteen-year-old who seems four years ahead can make your own child look unfinished. Joseph Allen followed teens like her for a decade. What his research found, and why a slower social timeline is not a problem to fix.

Whatever Happened to the Cool Kids
Peers
Drawing on research by
Joseph P. Allen (University of Virginia)
·
Read the study →

Every parent of a thirteen year old knows the family. Their daughter is six months older than yours in calendar terms and about four years older in every other way. She has the clothes. She has the group. She has a confidence at drop-off that makes your own child look, to you, painfully unfinished.

And you have had the thought. You would not say it out loud and you are not proud of it, but you have had it. Is mine behind?

I want to put a decade-long study in front of that thought, because it answers the question more precisely than reassurance does.

Joseph Allen is a professor of psychology at the University of Virginia, and in 2014 he and his colleagues published a paper in Child Development with one of the best titles in developmental science. "What Ever Happened to the 'Cool' Kids?"

They had followed a group of young people from the age of thirteen for a decade. At thirteen they identified the ones doing what the researchers called pseudomature behavior, which is the technical phrase for acting older than you are in order to be taken as older than you are. Minor rule-breaking. Early romantic pairing. Prizing appearance and status. The things that, at thirteen, purchase a great deal of social standing very quickly.

Those young people were popular. That part is not in dispute, and anyone who went to middle school can confirm it without a grant.

Then the researchers kept watching. By their early twenties, that same group was faring worse than their peers on several measures of how a young adult's life was actually going.

What interests me is less which measures than why any of them would move, because the explanation is the same whichever one you look at. The skill that wins a room at thirteen is the skill of presenting a version. The skill that holds a relationship at twenty-three is the skill of being known. They are not the same skill, and practicing the first one intensively, during the years you would otherwise be practicing the second, leaves you expert at something that stops being useful at roughly the moment it matters most.

This is the fifth book in The Unmistakably You Series, Glow Up. For Real., and the distinction in its title is exactly the distinction in Allen's data. There is a glow up that is a performance of having arrived, and there is a glow up that is the slow and unglamorous business of actually becoming someone. The first is visible immediately. The second is not visible for years. At thirteen, only one of them has any social value at all, which is why so many capable young people choose it, and why the choice is so hard for a parent to argue against in real time.

So what do you do with this at your own kitchen table.

Not this: do not hand your child the study. "Research shows the popular kids turn out worse" is both a misreading and a gift to nobody. It is smug, it is schadenfreude dressed as parenting, and it tells a thirteen year old that her social pain is a price worth paying for a payoff in a decade, which is not a trade any thirteen year old has ever accepted.

Do this instead. Stop treating her slower social timeline as a problem to be solved. Much of the pressure a young teenager feels to perform maturity is not coming from her peers at all. It is coming from adults who are anxious on her behalf and who signal that anxiety constantly, in questions about who she sat with and whether she has been invited. If you can take your own worry out of the room, you have removed a meaningful share of the demand.

And give her the other thing to practice. Allen's constructive work, including the Hoos Connected program at Virginia, is built on deliberately engineering authentic connection rather than hoping it happens. The domestic version is ordinary: unstructured time with a small number of people, no audience, nothing being documented. It looks like nothing. It is the rep that pays at twenty-three.

For educators. The implication for a school is about what gets rewarded in the first weeks of an academic year, when status in a cohort is set and then holds for a long time. If the only visible routes to standing in your building are performance routes, the students who are not ready to perform will conclude they have no route. The cheapest correction is to engineer situations in which standing can be earned through sustained, unglamorous contribution to a small group, and to make sure the adults notice that version out loud.

Your child is not behind. She is on a longer build. The other family's daughter is further along a road that, in Allen's data, tends to run out, and nobody in that drop-off line can see it yet.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

pass me a note

New reads, when they drop

Get the next piece the day it drops, plus the check-in that shows where you're editing yourself.

You're on the list. New reads land in your inbox the day they drop.
That didn't go through. Check your email address and try again.