Ask a group of fourteen year olds what they are like and you will get a shrug and a list of adjectives they think sound acceptable. Ask them which parts of themselves they leave at the classroom door and the room changes. They know. They answer fast, and in detail, and the detail is specific to your building.
That difference, between what a teenager will volunteer and what she can describe when asked precisely, is the whole subject of Leoandra Onnie Rogers's research, and it is the most useful thing an educator can know about adolescent identity.
Rogers is an associate professor of comparative human development at the University of Chicago. Her work sits in a tradition that treats identity not as something that unfolds privately inside a young person, like a plant growing, but as something negotiated against the scripts a young person is handed. The scripts arrive early, they are specific, and adolescents are far more conscious of them than adults tend to assume.
In 2025, with Moin Syed and a colleague, she published a study in the Journal of Adolescent Research whose title is a quotation from one of the young people in it. "I'm just a girl; not a white girl." Sit with the construction of that sentence. It is not a statement of what she is. It is a statement of what she is refusing, built by subtraction, in the presence of a category she did not choose and cannot avoid.
That is identity as negotiation, and it is happening in your corridors.
This is the second book in The Unmistakably You Series, Different on Purpose, and its argument is that difference is not an accident to be managed but a position to be taken deliberately. Rogers's data is the clearest evidence I know of that adolescents are already doing this, already running the calculation, already deciding which version of themselves a given room will tolerate. The question for a school is not whether students are editing. They are. The question is what your building is teaching them to edit out.
Here is why that question belongs to educators specifically rather than to counselors. The editing is context-dependent. A student does not have one self she suppresses everywhere. She has a reading of each setting, and she adjusts to each one. Which means the adjustment she makes in a chemistry class is information about that chemistry class. It is feedback, delivered in the only form available to her, and most of it never reaches anyone who could act on it.
Three practical consequences follow.
The first is that the usual question does not work. "Do you feel like you belong here?" invites the answer the student believes you want, and by fourteen she is fluent in producing it. Rogers's method gets better material because it asks for narrative rather than rating, and because it asks about situations rather than feelings. "Tell me about a time you decided not to say something in class" will out-produce any climate survey item you have.
The second is that the parts being edited out are not random. They cluster around whatever your setting has quietly coded as not serious, not academic, not appropriate here. Sometimes that coding is in a policy. More often it is in what gets praised in September and what gets a raised eyebrow, and nobody wrote it down, which is exactly why it is hard to find and easy to fix once found.
The third is the one worth taking to a staff meeting. If a student is making a situational judgment rather than suffering a general deficit, then the intervention is situational too. You do not need to build her confidence. You need to change what your room rewards. That is a smaller job than it sounds, and it is one a single teacher can do without a budget line.
There is an obvious objection, and it deserves a straight answer. Is a teenager who adjusts to a classroom not simply learning the ordinary social skill of adapting to context, which adults do constantly and call professionalism? Sometimes, yes. Adapting is not the same as erasing. The distinction Rogers's narrative work makes visible is whether the young person experiences the adjustment as a choice she is making or as a condition of entry she had no part in setting. The first builds range. The second builds the habit this series exists to interrupt.
So the next time you are tempted to ask a group of students whether they feel they belong, ask them instead what they do not bring into your room. They will know. They have known for a while. The only new thing in the exchange will be that somebody finally asked precisely enough to get the real answer.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
This essay was first published on Conviction Chronicles

